Mixed
Waste Soil Remediation
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Client: WDNR/HSI Geotrans
Click Here to Download this
Case Study in PDF Format
SITUATION
In the 1950s
and 60s, the property at 3033 West Walnut Street was being utilized
as a plating operation for Electro-coatings. Following shut down of
operations, the soils within the area of the operation were found to
be contaminated with Hexavalent Chrome and chlorinated VOCs (e.g., PCE,
TCE, etc.). Results of a site characterization indicated approximately
14,400 tons of impacted soil to a depth of 40 feet. VOC contaminated
soils were expected to be less than 7,700 ppm.
The Wisconsin
Department of Natural Resources (WDNR) elected to remediate the site
under a publicly funded approach. Two separate bid options were evaluated:
1) Treat metals in-place, Excavate and remove VOC soils as hazardous
and incinerate; 2) Treat metals soils in-place and perform IN-SITU hot-air
treatment on VOC soils to lower/eliminate contamination levels to meet
a non-hazardous classification for off-site disposal. In order to meet
the State's treatment level, site soils had to be treated to less than
5 mg/l TCLP, Leachable Chrome, 14 ppm for PCE and 5 ppm for TCE. Bid
option 2 was selected due to cost savings.
CBA's
TECHNOLOGY AND APPROACH
CBA's innovative
technology was considered instrumental for IN-SITU hot-air soil treatment
by the WDNR's prime contracting firm, HSI Geotrans. The primary objective
was to utilize the IN-SITU soil treatment technology that could meet
treatment objectives in accordance with the WDNR soil treatment criteria.
CBA focused on treating the soils in shallow lifts that would be selectively
removed following treatment.
RESULTS
At the request of
the WDNR, CBA began IN-SITU soil treatment work on Lift No. 1 in late
December. Post-treatment results indicated VOC levels of 15,000 ppm
in one of the grids. Based on treatment time, it was estimated that
PCE soils within that grid were likely at or near 25,000 ppm prior to
treatment. CBA completed IN-SITU soil treatment on chrome-contaminated
soils in rapid fashion and continued to use hot-air treatment on VOC
contaminated soils. While performing under adverse winter weather conditions,
heavy precipitation and the presence of marine clays, CBA was able to
meet the treatment objectives for TCE and achieve 99% mass removal from
the PCE soils (i.e., to about 100 ppm) with hot-air only. CBA and HSI
collectively approached the WDNR and proposed the additional use of
chemical amendments (i.e., chemical oxidation) in order to meet the
optimal treatment objective of 14 ppm for the VOC contaminated soils.
Bench-scale and
pilot scale work was performed on VOC soils. The results indicated that
mixing the appropriate amount of potassium permanganate with the MITU
rendered the soils non-hazardous (i.e., less than 14 ppm for PCE). The
CBA/HSI team proposed this revised approach that was still $4.4 MM less
than Option No. 1.
Project Manager:
Clark A. Romberger
Site Manager: Mike Siravo
Bid Cost: $1.85 Million
Client Contact Reference: Tom Wentland, Project Mgr., WDNR (414) 229-0853
HSI Project Manager: Rich Gnat (262) 792-1282